Problem Gambling Seven Times More Common on Illegal Sites

Problem gambling is far more common on illegal sites, according to new UK Gambling Commission research. The regulator's banking-data study found that players using unlicensed sites were much more to score in the highest risk band than people on licensed sites. For anyone weighing up casino bonuses or a new sportsbook, it's a blunt reminder: the licence on the homepage matters more than the welcome offer.

What did the UKGC actually find about problem gambling?

The Gambling Commission found a much higher rate of problem gambling among people using illegal sites than among those on licensed ones. The study drew on banking transaction data, supplied by YouGov, covering tens of millions of transactions from tens of thousands of people. It flagged thousands of transactions as suspected illegal gambling, tied to a few hundred individuals.

The scores tell the story. A large share of players on illegal websites scored eight or higher on the Problem Gambling Severity Index, the top risk category. Only a small fraction of licensed-site gamblers did. A further group of illegal users landed in the moderate band, against a smaller share of licensed customers.

One honest caveat: the research doesn't prove illegal sites cause the harm. It shows a strong link, not a cause.

Do illegal site users stop using licensed casinos?

No, and that's the finding that should worry anyone who runs a best online casinos shortlist. Most of the people with at least two detected illegal transactions also gambled with licensed companies. Their monthly licensed activity barely moved: the number of transactions in the month before their first illegal payment was close to the number in the month after.

The report's own words are that illegal gambling is "embedded within existing gambling behavior" rather than sparking a shift away from the licensed market. In plain terms, black-market sites sit alongside your normal casino and sportsbook accounts. They don't replace them.

Why is this a casino safety story, not just a betting one?

Casino safety comes down to who holds the licence, and this study shows why that's not a box-ticking exercise. The UK Gambling Commission can only act on operators it licenses. Unlicensed sites sit outside deposit limits, outside self-exclusion, and outside any route to a payout dispute.

Detection is genuinely hard, too. Black-market operators rarely put their real names on bank statements, so investigators leaned on merchant codes and transaction patterns. Crypto transfers and alternative payment rails fell outside the data entirely. That's why the Commission says it can't size Britain's illegal market. The Betting and Gaming Council has been less shy, warning in August that black-market Premier League betting alone could reach £1 billion by the 2027/28 season.

What should smart players do?

Check the licence before you deposit, and check it on the regulator's own register rather than trusting a logo. Stick to UKGC-licensed brands for casino games and sportsbook bets, and use the responsible gambling tools on those sites: deposit limits, time-outs, and self-exclusion through GAMSTOP.

If a site offers big bonuses but you can't find a licence number, walk away. If you're already mixing a licensed account with an unlicensed one, that's the pattern this research flags hardest. Free, confidential help is available at BeGambleAware.org.

What the risk gap means for you

This story isn't about banning anything. It's about where you play. The gap between the two risk bands is the clearest argument yet for keeping your casino and betting activity on licensed sites. and for treating an unlicensed bonus as a red flag rather than a bargain. If you only gamble with UKGC-licensed operators and use their limits, you're already on the safer side of that split. If you're not sure about a site, skip it.

The bottom line for players

The UK Gambling Commission research points to one conclusion for casino players: the licence behind a site is the single most important thing to check before you deposit. Illegal sites sit outside deposit limits, self-exclusion and payout disputes, and the study links them to far higher problem-gambling scores. Smart players stick to UKGC-licensed brands, use the responsible gambling tools on those sites, and walk away from any bonus that comes without a verifiable licence. If you're unsure about a site, skip it. Free, confidential help is available at BeGambleAware.org.

For support and to set deposit, loss or time limits, see BeGambleAware and GamCare.

18+. Play responsibly.