Skip to content
BestCasinoPortal
Play

18+ Play responsibly BeGambleAware.org

Industry

Evolution Settles With Law Firm That Circulated Playtech-Funded 'Smear' Report

By Daniel Cheung 4 min read

Evolution's settlement with Calcagni & Kanefsky LLP, confirmed in New Jersey Superior Court on 17 November 2026. removes the law firm from Evolution's defamation case against Black Cube. The Evolution settlement settles law, but only partly. For casino players, it shows how supplier disputes and licensing investigations can shake the brands behind your favourite games.

What does the Evolution settlement mean for casino players?

The Evolution settlement means a New Jersey law firm that passed a disputed report to regulators is now out of the defamation case. The wider fight over that report carries on. Calcagni & Kanefsky submitted the 2021 report to gaming regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. That triggered investigations and heavy press coverage. Evolution's share price fell hard at the time, wiping billions off its market value.

Here's the bit that matters if you play Evolution titles like Crazy Time or Lightning Roulette. The games were never pulled from licensed markets after the probe. New Jersey's Division of Gaming Enforcement closed its investigation in February 2024 without action. It found no evidence Evolution knowingly allowed or profited from its products in prohibited jurisdictions. That's the regulator's finding, not ours. It's also the closest thing to a clean bill of health the supplier has had.

Why should bettors care who funds a report?

Bettors should care because a competitor-funded report can move share prices and trigger licensing probes. In theory, it can affect which suppliers stay live at your casino. Court proceedings in October 2025 revealed that Playtech, one of Evolution's biggest rivals, commissioned the Black Cube investigation. Evolution now accuses Playtech of running an anticompetitive smear campaign and hiding its involvement for years.

Playtech says it commissioned the probe but denies wrongdoing. It argues the report raised legitimate concerns. Black Cube is pushing to have the case thrown out under New Jersey's Uniform Public Expression Protection Act. Its lawyers called the settlement a "white flag of surrender" while claiming it involved no payment. Evolution hasn't confirmed the terms.

What does this mean for you? Very little at the felt. What it does show is how much of the casino supply chain sits behind the games you spin. When we check how we rate casinos, supplier stability and licensing history are part of the picture. A supplier under investigation can spook operators and regulators alike.

Could Playtech be next, and does it affect your casino?

Playtech could be next, because Evolution sought permission in April 2026 to add its rival and other parties to the lawsuit. Judge John Porto rejected that request without prejudice in June. He ruled that Black Cube's UPEPA challenge should be heard first. So the case rolls on. The settlement removes one firm but not the central dispute.

For players, the practical effect is nil right now. Evolution games remain live at licensed operators. Playtech's own titles sit on plenty of the same lobbies. If you're picking where to play, focus on the operator's licence and payout record rather than the supplier drama. Our best online casinos page ranks brands on exactly that.

What smart players should do with this story

Smart players should treat the Evolution settlement as industry noise, not a signal to change their casino habits. The useful takeaway is about transparency. A report can be anonymous and funded by a rival, and still spark a multi-year legal fight. That's why licensing and regulatory checks matter more than any single headline.

Check that your casino holds a valid licence. Read the bonus terms before you deposit. Use responsible gambling tools if play stops feeling fun. If you want to compare welcome offers safely, our casino bonuses guide explains wagering in plain English. And if gambling is causing you stress, BeGambleAware.org offers free, confidential support.

The bottom line for players

Evolution settles law firm disputes with no confirmed finding against its games. New Jersey's regulator already closed its probe in February 2024 with no action. For casino players, the story is a reminder to judge operators on licensing, payout reliability and responsible gambling tools, not on supplier gossip. Stick to licensed casinos. Read the terms. Set limits before you play.

For support and to set deposit, loss or time limits, see BeGambleAware and GamCare.

18+. Play responsibly.

18+ only. Gambling should be entertainment, never a way to make money. Set a budget before you play and stick to it. If gambling stops being fun, take a break — free, confidential help is available at BeGambleAware and our responsible-gambling tools.

Keep reading

Related

Compare on the money pages

This story is news, not a ranking. Open a hub if you want the Trust Index list.

Topics

Tagged

18+ only. Gamble responsibly. Free, confidential help is available at BeGambleAware, GamCare and Gambling Therapy.

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission when you sign up via our links. This never changes our Trust Index or rating order. Read the full disclosure.

Reviewed by the BestCasinoPortal editorial team. Updated: .